Hammock Tent vs Tent on Rocky or Hard-Ground Campsites

Two Haven hammock tents on a rocky alpine ridge

Hammock tent or ground tent on rocky, hard-ground campsites? If there are trees (or you bring a stand), a hammock tent is usually the easier and more comfortable choice: the ground under you doesn't matter, so rocks, roots, slope and packed dirt stop being a problem, and you don't need to drive stakes into anything. Where there's nothing to hang from, like slickrock, scree or a gravel bar with no trees, a freestanding ground tent is simpler, because it stands up without stakes. A Haven can still pitch on the ground in bivy mode there, but then you're on the rock like everyone else.

Two Haven hammock tents on a rocky alpine ridge, one hung from a tree and one pitched on the ground

Why rocky ground is hard on tents

  • Finding a flat spot. You need a patch the size of your tent that is level and free of sharp stones. On rocky sites that spot may not exist.
  • Stakes won't go in. Many tents need stakes for the corners, vestibules and guylines. On rock and hardpan you tie off to boulders instead, which takes time.
  • You feel every lump. A pad softens it, but a rock under your hip is still there at 2 a.m. (see How to Stop Waking Up Sore After Sleeping in a Tent).
  • Wear on the floor. Sharp rock can abrade or puncture a tent floor and an air pad. A footprint helps.

Why a hammock tent handles it better (with trees)

A hung hammock tent only touches the ground with its guylines. You need two healthy trees or other solid anchors, about 12 to 15 ft apart for a Haven, and what's between them can be boulders, roots or a slope. A Haven's flat platform and insulated pad give you the same bed on a rocky ridge as in a pine forest. The same goes for river trips where flat, dry ground is scarce, like our packrafting trip on the Happy River in Alaska.

Comparison

Ground tent (freestanding)Hammock tent, hungHammock tent in bivy mode
Needs a flat, clear spotYesNoYes
Needs anchorsStakes or rocks for guylinesTwo trees, a stand or a hitch mountTwo poles or sticks, plus stakes or rocks for guylines
Comfort on lumpy groundDepends on your padUnaffectedDepends on the spot; the pad helps
Wear from rockFloor and pad at risk; use a footprintNoneUse a footprint (we recommend one for the Spectre's mesh body)
PeopleOne or moreOne per hammockOne

Tips for rocky campsites

With a Haven

  • Check the anchors first. Trees growing in rocky soil can be shallow-rooted. Use only healthy, solid trees, look up for dead branches, and keep the hang low (hang safe).
  • Use rocks for the guylines. If stakes won't go in, tie the rainfly guylines around a heavy rock or a boulder.
  • Bring longer suspension if trees are widely spaced; Whoopie Slings or Spectre Straps add reach.
  • No trees? Pitch in bivy mode on the smoothest spot you can find, with a footprint under it. The Haven Spectre's mesh body isn't waterproof, so we recommend a footprint under it on the ground. More in Going to Ground.

With a ground tent

  • Choose a freestanding tent, and carry a footprint.
  • Clear loose stones before you pitch and lie down to test the spot.
  • Use a thicker pad, and tie guylines to rocks when stakes won't hold.

Which should you choose?

  • Rocky sites with trees (forests, river corridors, canyon bottoms): a hammock tent.
  • Treeless rock, scree or alpine sites: a freestanding ground tent, or a Haven in bivy mode if you also camp among trees.
  • Car camping on gravel or hardpan: a Haven on the Haven Stand on firm, reasonably level ground, or a tent with a good pad.

Read Hammock Tent vs Ground Tent for the backpacking trade-offs, Using a Hammock Tent at Campgrounds for developed sites, and see when a ground tent wins on our Haven vs Ground Tents page. Our outdoor sleep systems page shows every model.

Comments (0)

No comments yet — be the first!

Leave a Comment

Related Articles

← Back to Adventure Journal