Lay-Flat Hammock vs Regular Hammock: Which Is More Comfortable?

Two Haven hammock tents hanging side by side in an autumn forest

Lay-flat hammock or regular hammock: which is more comfortable? For a full night's sleep, most people find a lay-flat hammock more comfortable, especially side and stomach sleepers, because it holds you flat instead of curving you into a banana shape. A regular gathered-end hammock is often the better choice for lounging, for the lightest and cheapest setup, and for back sleepers who already sleep well lying diagonally. Comfort also depends on setup: a well-hung regular hammock can feel better than a badly hung lay-flat one.

Two Haven hammock tents hanging side by side in an autumn forest

How each one feels

A regular (gathered-end) hammock is a length of fabric gathered at each end. Your weight pulls it into a curve, so your head and feet sit higher than your hips and the sides wrap around your shoulders. Lying at an angle across it, the "diagonal lay", flattens you out a good deal, and many back sleepers sleep well that way.

A lay-flat hammock uses some structure to keep the sleeping surface level. In a Haven, two support arcs keep the side walls low, spreader bars stop the sides closing in, a ridgeline holds the shape whatever the tree spacing, and an insulated air mattress makes a firm platform. The result feels closer to a bed than a sling. The design post explains each part.

Comfort by sleeping position

Regular gathered-end hammockLay-flat hammock (Haven)
BackGood for many people, lying diagonallyFlat, like a bed
SideHard for most: the curve and squeezed shouldersDesigned for it
StomachVery hard; your back arches the wrong wayPossible, as on a firm mattress
Rolling overAwkward; the fabric shifts with youRoll over as you would at home
Lounging and sittingExcellent; this is what it's made forSit on the edge or lie back; the Safari and Spectre have a lounge strap that turns the bed into a reclined seat

Stability and getting in

A regular hammock is stable when it hangs with a deep sag, but that's what bends you into the banana shape. Pull it tight to flatten it and it gets tippy. A Haven keeps its anchor points high above the sleeping platform and carries the tension down the side arcs, so you get a flat bed that doesn't tip. You get in by sitting on the low side wall and lying back, and you can hold the ridgeline while you do. More in What Makes a Hammock Stable, or Not?

What you need for an overnight

For a night out, a regular hammock needs extras: tree straps, a bug net, a tarp, and an underquilt or pad for warmth. Each one is a separate purchase and something to set up. A Haven kit comes with the bug net, rainfly, straps, guylines, stakes and an insulated air mattress; you add your sleeping bag and pillow. See the gear checklist for a side-by-side list.

Where a regular hammock does better

  • Weight and pack size. A bare gathered-end hammock is much lighter and smaller than any lay-flat hammock tent.
  • Price. A basic hammock costs far less up front, even after you add a tarp and net.
  • Lounging. For an afternoon in the shade, the cocoon feel is the point.
  • Simplicity. Two straps and you're hanging.
  • Weight capacity. The ENO and Kammok hammocks we compared are rated higher than a Haven's 285 lb (350 lb for the Safari); see Haven vs Kammok and ENO, and check each maker's rating.

Where a lay-flat hammock does better

  • Sleeping on your side or stomach.
  • Not spending the night in a curve, with the sides pressing on your shoulders.
  • Warmth, because the insulated pad is built in.
  • One kit instead of matching a net, tarp and insulation.

Which should you choose?

  • You mostly lounge, nap or backpack light, and sleep on your back: a regular hammock, hung with a good sag and slept in diagonally.
  • You want to sleep through the night on your side or stomach: a lay-flat hammock such as the Haven Tent or Haven XL.
  • You want something in between: a bridge hammock is flatter than a gathered-end one and lighter than a Haven (see Haven vs Warbonnet and Amok).

Not sure a lay-flat hammock is worth it for you? Read Are Lay-Flat Hammocks Worth It?, Can You Sleep Flat in a Hammock? and the brand comparison Haven vs Kammok and ENO. To compare a Haven with a ground tent, see Haven vs Ground Tents, and see every model on our outdoor sleep systems page.

Comments (0)

No comments yet — be the first!

Leave a Comment

Related Articles

← Back to Adventure Journal